Shoot to Incapacitate??
On October 14, 2026, Shjarback and Stoughton had an article published entitled “ A note on ‘shoot to incapacitate’ deadly force policies”. Both Shjarback and Stoughton are academics and this article gives their opinions on these types of polices, and their supposed research to substantiate their opinions.
Screenshot of Article

What I think is particularly hilarious about this article begins in the second sentence of the abstract: “Starting in 2021, officers in the LaGrange (Georgia) Police Department (LPD) were formally trained that they now have the option of lowering their point of aim to the lower abdomen and upper thigh region (i.e. pelvic girdle) under certain circumstances – namely when confronted by an individual who presents a deadly threat in the form of an edged weapon or blunt object (i.e. melee weapons).
They then delve into the policy the LaGrange PD developed concerning ‘shoot to incapacitate’, which was implemented under Chief L. Dekmar. The article even mentions the pushback to this “controversial approach” from local Georgia police executives, Force Science®, and the fact that this policy has received local and national media attention. Specific reference was made towards the 2021 Annual Peace Officers Association of Georgia (POAG Conference) in which this policy came up in a discussion panel.
Shjarback makes the remark several pages into his article that there is always a fear of changing use of force policies that would jeopardize officer safety. HA! You think?!?
I’ll leave the article for you to read and make your own opinion, but I must say that ‘shoot to incapacitate’ is an asinine approach to any deadly force situation. Policies like this oftentimes are stricter than statutory law, and it is definitely stricter than the decisions brought forth by the U.S. Supreme Court.
I will, however, definitely state the following:
I was in attendance at the 2021 Annual Peace Officers Association of Georgia (POAG Conference) and sat in on the panel discussion that Shjarback references. I recall that the main ones on the panel that supported LaGrange’s ‘shoot to incapacitate’ policy were mostly academics. Police tactics experts, human behavioral researchers, and lawyers were the opponents of this type of policy. Eric Daigle, founder and principal attorney of Daigle Law Group, was on the panel and stated that he would not defend a policy of this sort.
This article has a publish date of October 2026. The policy that is the main focus of the article was distributed in 2021. However, to show the lack of thoroughness in Shjarback’s and Stoughton’s research, a new police chief was hired by LaGrange in 2023; who is still currently the police chief in 2026. I personally know the chief and I know that one of his first actions was to remove the ‘shoot to incapacitate’ from the departmental policy. I learned this after speaking to him shortly after his hiring.
During the development and implementation of Dekmar’s ‘shoot to incapacitate’ policy in 2021, I got involved when I was asked (via email) to review the policy by one of LPD’s training officers. My reply was that this type of policy is not only contradictory to statutory and constitutional requirements, it is unrealistic to how an officer may use their firearm under stress. I also questioned the legal liability that may be incurred because of such a policy. The tactic itself wasn’t debated that much, but this is the instance where I was told that the constitutional requirements of Graham v Connor were outdated and that the public demanded more.
The October 2026 article wraps up with discussing public perception and how citizens may view ‘shoot to incapacitate’ policies in an effort to reduce deadly force. When did public perception become a factor in a 4th Amendment law enforcement interaction? The decision of Graham v Connor may be dated 1989; however, it is not outdated. This 1989 decision is still used as a precedent in the current U.S. Supreme Court Decision involving free citizen/law enforcement interactions. To this date, all use of force must be analyzed from the perception of the officer on scene at the time force was used; not from the perception of the public. I appreciate the quote in Vaughan v. Cox, 343 F.3d 1323 (11th Cir. 2003) that states “[w]e are loath to second-guess the decisions made by police officers in the field.”
Police policy must be grounded in constitutional law, operational reality, sound training, and officer safety—not in unrealistic theories.




Comments