Academic's Opinion on Law Enforcement Response to a Suicidal Subject
Alleged facts of the incident (still under investigation as of this blog):
Date and time: September 17, 2026 at 2244 hours
Location: West Lovers Lane, Arlington, Texas
Dispatch: 911 call
Subject: David Eversole, 56-yrs-old, experiencing mental/suicide crisis
Law Enforcement: 4 officers from Arlington Police Department
The 911 caller indicated that a man in the home, who was identified as 56-year-old David Eversole, was making suicidal comments and had access to knives.
Four officers responded to the home. The 911 caller met them at the front door and led them to the room Mr. Eversole was in. As officers approached the room, they could hear yelling and learned that a family member was also in the room with Mr. Eversole.
Officers opened the door to the room and got the family member out. One of the officers then entered the room. Mr. Eversole became upset and pulled out a large knife. The officer gave Mr. Eversole multiple verbal commands to drop the knife, but he did not comply. As the officer started backing out of the room, Mr. Eversole came towards him still holding the knife. The officer fired his service weapon multiple times, striking Mr. Eversole.
Immediately following the shooting, officers provided first aid to Mr. Eversole until paramedics arrived. Mr. Eversole was transported to an area hospital where he later died.
No officers and no others in the home were injured during this incident.
As is the standard of the Arlington Police Department, anytime an officer uses deadly force, two investigations are initiated:
A criminal investigation led by the APD Homicide Unit, which will review the incident to determine if any criminal offenses were committed.
An administrative investigation led by the APD Internal Affairs Unit, which will determine whether the officers followed department policies and procedures.

Image obtained from released BWC footage
This incident came to my attention when I saw an opinion piece on LinkedIn from a third-party observer; who incidentally is an academic. Their critique focused on several things that concerned me:
They focused on the fact that the officers entered the home within 90 seconds of first contacting the 911 caller; however, there is no mention of the family member that was in the room with Eversole.
Stated that the suicidal man produced a knife, threatened the officers and moved towards the officers when one shot him.
They were concerned that there was no explicit discussion of a plan.
Gave the assumption, without speaking with the officers on scene, that the officers were compelled to make contact with Eversole because of what he could do to the family member that was with him.
Stated that officers focus on “hypothetical harm” (yes, his words) and then they built a narrative around “what might happen”.
Questioned that just because an action may “be legally defensible”, is that action one law enforcement should continue to use; or, should law enforcement look at other approaches.
I understand that law enforcement response to suicidal subjects has changed over the years. I also understand that suicidal tendencies are not an actual mental disorder, but that those tendencies could be the product of a mental illness. It has been debated, even in our state CIT unit that I managed, what actions should an officer take when dealing with a suicidal subject.
It is not against the law for someone to want to or actually harm themselves. Without a commitment order (examples: Georgia – 1013 hold; California – 5150 hold; New York – Mental Hygiene Law [MHL] hold), officers oftentimes are afraid to take suicidal subjects into protective custody. Treatment options may be suggested such as medical help, but if the person is alone and refuses intervention, it is policy in some areas that tell officers they must leave. In these instances, this prevents the accusation of some sort of 4th Amendment violation by the suicidal subject. However, when other parties are present and may be in harm’s way, then officers then have to make a judgment call on what actions to take.
Hopefully, the analysis performed by the Arlington Police Department of these officers’ actions will not mirror the thoughts of the third-party academic previously mentioned. Any analysis should be performed from an objective standpoint:
Did the officers have the legal authority to enter the residence?
Did the officers believe there was an imminent threat towards the family member that was in the room with Eversole?
Did the officers act legally in their use of force against Eversole?
If the answer is “yes” to all the above, then the officers acted accordingly to constitutional, state and administrative requirements.
It is important to note that no incident should be looked at from “what should the officers have done”; all incidents should be looked at from “could the officer legally do that?”
From the facts that I know from the press release, if I was the officer responding to this call, I would have most likely entered the house and the room as I would be concerned of what would have happened if I had delayed entry into the house.
Officers are called upon to make split-second decisions in situations that are tense, uncertain and rapidly evolving. However, oftentimes these split-second decisions are then questioned by a practitioner or someone who has never worn a badge or have been in a situation like this. In my opinion, if you have never placed yourself in a potentially dangerous situation to protect someone that you do not personally know, then maybe you should leave the job to the professionals that are trained for these situations.




Comments