top of page
unnamed.png
Search

Raising the Standard for Using Force?

Oct 23
3 min read

Updated: Oct 26

This is somewhat of a continuance from the last blog. It is amazing how third-party organizations attempt to influence the innerworkings of law enforcement, especially when it pertains to our authority to use force if needed. Stanford Law School released a policy brief earlier this year where one of the main takeaways was “Graham v Connor establishes a troublingly low threshold for police behavior.” In this brief they promote their Model Use of Force Policy which in their words, expands on the Graham standard and provides a checklist that an officer must follow before using force.


When I read this brief, it is troubling to me as not only a use of force expert witness, but also as a sworn law enforcement officer. In my opinion, Stanford’s brief discusses concepts that you can tell were not designed by someone who has been in the field to any extent. They reference authors such as Brandon Garrett and Seth Stoughton who definitely have expressed their opinions that the U.S. Supreme Court has misinterpreted the safeguards that the Fourth Amendment provides. Stoughton has advocated that “community expectations” should be one of the determining factors in analyzing use of force.


The model approach that Stanford proposes contains the following:


  • Officers must use available non-force options and issue verbal warnings before using force.


The US Supreme Court and some lower appellate courts have established precedence by making numerous decisions that law enforcement officers are not required to use non-force options (Roell v Hamilton, 870 F.3d 471, 6th Cir. 2017) or verbal warning (Tennessee v Garner, 471 U.S. 1, 1985) before using force. We discussed the aspects of law enforcement de-escalation on Episode 2 of Blue Line Objective (YouTube©).


  • Force should only be employed to achieve a lawful objective, and only the minimum force necessary should be used.


First, law enforcement officers are taught that you can only use force when fulfilling a lawful objective, so it is mute to reiterate this. Second, where does the word “minimum” fall in the Graham decision? It does not. Plus, if you want to get hung up on verbiage, a variation of minimum can be defined as “barely adequate”. So, Stanford is suggesting that we our force needs to be “barely adequate”? Imagine how many times that would be used in a civil suit against law enforcement officers and agencies.


  • The force used must be necessary and proportionate to the situation.


Again, where does the word “necessary” or “proportionate” appear in Graham? It does not.


  • The totality of the circumstances should be considered when evaluating any use of force.

We are taught this! This is not a concept that needs to reiterated (well, maybe the 9th Circuit should hear more about it).


It is disturbing to note that research shows that from the largest police departments in the U.S., 48% have removed “reasonable” from their departmental policy on use of force and replaced it with “necessary” and 79% have mandated de-escalation, making more stringent constraints on officer discretion than the constitutional law requires.


Thankfully, some states have in their statutes that stipulate that if any policy, rule or regulation put in place by a law enforcement agency or government agency that is more restricted than what constitutional law allows, that guideline will be null and void (examples: Georgia – OCGA 17-4-20(d); Florida – Florida Constitution Art. 5 Section 21; Texas – TX Government Code Section 2001.035; Ohio Rev. Code Section 106.021).


Is any use of force “pretty”? NO! Anything an officer has to use force it always appears to the untrained eye to be chaotic and even times violent. And, in hindsight, have officers made what appears to be bad decisions? A prime example is one of the first images that law enforcement trainers used to explain officer perception:



In the above image from 2003, it appears that the suspect in front of the in-car camera is pointing a gun at the officer who is off screen to the left of the image. The officer believed the same thing and shot the suspect. However, when the scene was under control, officers found out that the object the suspect was pointing at the officer was a chrome cell phone.


If officers were legally held to the standards set forth by Stanford Law School, would it be found that this officer used reasonable force? I’m afraid of what the answer to that question may be.


Law enforcement officers are human; we are not computers or robots. Since officers have to make “split-second decisions in situations that are tense, uncertain and rapidly evolving”, the courts set forth the guideline of reasonableness. I always teach in my course that an officer, in hindsight, does not have to be right; they only have to be reasonable.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Legally Reasonable; but was it necessary?

It seems that as political and societal influence infiltrates law enforcement procedure, officers now are held to a higher standard than originally determined by our justice system. I agree that to an

 
 
 
bottom of page